• MBM February 2012 cover thumbnail
  • MBY March 12 Cover
  • PBO March 2012 cover
  • Yachting Monthly February 2012
  • Yachting World February 2012 issue

Top tips for comparing policies...

Go for the cheapest and hope you don't need to claim, or go for the most expensive because that must be the best? Or take a more logical approach with our handy checklist.

Boat insurance guide

Here are some issues to consider when comparing policies.

  • If an accident happens because a worn out part fails, is the part excluded or is the claim rejected?
  • If there is a No Claims Bonus, is it protected at its maximum? If you have a claim, what is the effect on NCB in the following year?
  • Do the insurers need a condition survey? If not, and your boat is more than say, 10 years old, why not?
  • Is the policy an Agreed Fixed Value policy?
  • If a 'New for Old' deduction can be applied, does it apply to parts and materials only, or to all costs including labour costs?
  • What parts and/or equipment can be subject to deductions due to their age or condition when replaced following a claim?
  • Can 'average' be applied to claims, and if so, to what items?
  • Can 'betterment' be applied, and if so, to what items?
  • Are any claims settled on the basis of 'market value at time of loss'? If so, which?
  • Can the insurers elect to replace parts - or the boat itself - with those of a similar age and condition?
  • Do the insurers have the final say on where repairs are to be carried out?
  • Whose Personal Effects will be insured?
  • Is use of the vessel restricted in any way that may affect you - single handed sailing, night sailing, specified winter lay-up period, club racing etc?
  • Does the policy excess apply to all claims? If not, when does it apply?
  • Is liability covered under the same policy as damage to your own boat? Does the policy excess apply?
  • Will I be dealing with an insurance company directly or with an intermediary? How knowledgeable are the employees who will handle my policy?