Tony_M
regular
Reged: 02/07/2005
Posts: 115
Loc: Cardiff
|
|
Morning all, does the rule of twelfths work in the BC?
|
graham
regular
Reged: 16/05/2001
Posts: 5859
Loc: South Wales
|
|
Yes,it works very well.Sometimes it will be a bit out within an hour of low tide but the rest of the time its usefull.
--------------------
http://banjocoronado25.blogspot.com/
All Hardwood used in Banjos restoration comes from sustainable sources. Usually the Boat Club Skip :-)
|
wotayottie
regular
Reged: 01/07/2007
Posts: 1539
|
|
the rule of 12ths works reasonably anywhere where the tidal curve approximates to a sine wave. doubt that it would be worth much by the time you got to Lydney / Sharpness
|
PCUK
regular
Reged: 29/06/2005
Posts: 1718
Loc: Devon
|
|
A new European directive is now making it illegal as it is Imperial. A new rule of tenths is now mandatory for all EU countries. Gordon Brown is particularly keen on it, being the leader of Euro-Labour!
|
tonybarebones
regular
Reged: 20/09/2006
Posts: 193
Loc: Dinas Powis, Vale of Glamorgan
|
|
This for those who may be unfamilier with the Rule of Twelths... 
TIDES: Estimating tide rise and fall. The simplest rule of thumb for the guestimation of the height and speed of flow of the tide is the twelfths rule:
1 Hr. after low/hi water 1/12 of the tide height will rise/fall
2 Hr. after low/hi water 2/12 of the tide height will rise/fall
3 Hr. after low/hi water 3/12 of the tide height will rise/fall
4 Hr. after low/hi water 3/12 of the tide height will rise/fall
5 Hr. after low/hi water 2/12 of the tide height will rise/fall
6 Hr. after low/hi water 1/12 of the tide height will rise/fall
The speed of flow of the tide is approximately proportional to the amount of rise per hour, thus the fastest tide flows will occur at mid tide.
For greater detail consult a local chart and tidal atlas.
TME DIFFERENCES ON CARDIFF
Avonmouth +15 min
Barry - 15 min
Ilfracombe - 60 min
Milford Haven - 60 min
Minehead - 20 min
Newport +10 min
Swansea +45 min
INTERESTING FACTS: When during a year can we expect to find the largest tides? A day or two after the full or new moon nearest to the equinoxes. The spring equinox is usually the 21st March, and the autumn equinox, the 23rd September.
Some years have tides that are notably higher than other years. 1997 was a significant year, as will be the year 2015. For really favourable conditions - you will have to wait around until the year 3182. Even then, the tides may only be 1 or 2 cm higher than in 1997.
|
graham
regular
Reged: 16/05/2001
Posts: 5859
Loc: South Wales
|
|
Quote:
you will have to wait around until the year 3182. Even then, the tides may only be 1 or 2 cm higher than in 1997
Could you remind us a bit closer to the time.I'll take some pictures and post them on here. 
--------------------
http://banjocoronado25.blogspot.com/
All Hardwood used in Banjos restoration comes from sustainable sources. Usually the Boat Club Skip :-)
|
Damo
regular
Reged: 22/02/2005
Posts: 2613
Loc: k keeper,Portishead
|
|
A YM instructor once told me that it wouldn't be adviseable to use the twelfths rule in the BC, because of the big ranges. So being a contrary bu**er I took about 20 tides from 2007, with a range of springs and neaps, and found some averages.
The twelfths agreed with Belfield, Reeds and WTides to within a few percent on time and height, so I now have a little excel table with ranges from 1m to 16m and the corresponding tide height for each hour.
I used to do all the calcs very carefully when anchoring to find minimum depths etc, but for the last couple of years, having seen what happens on a daily basis compared to prediction I think twelfths are as good as anything. ALL the different tables and programs are inadequate at some point, either the algorithms differ slightly so times/heights don't agree (eg Belfield is very accurate on Springs, and can be way out for LW Neaps), or the conditions on the day may surprise you.
For example, on the last neaps the tide turned an hour ahead of LW prediction, and the tidal heights on the ebb were about 1m below at predicted time. High pressure is said to depress the tide, but that's not always the case.
So if you want to calculate to the minute and centimetre in the BC, I would say don't bother. Using the Rule of Twelfths is sufficient, because IMHO if you plan to leave a few cms under your keel then you are asking for trouble. And if the tide goes against you when trying to get past that tidal gate (ie between Hartland and Sharpness  ) it may be that you haven't miscalculated - it's what it has decided to do on the day!
--------------------
Never be at a loose end with the Yosemite bowline 
|
Alcyone
regular
Reged: 09/04/2008
Posts: 208
Loc: Bridgend, Wales, UK
|
|
Ramsey Sound - the fastest rate of tide is at high/low water, and the slacks are around mid tide. As you move out, towards Grassholm and the Smalls, the slacks occur at 4 and then 5 hours after HW. Took me years to believe it, but it's true.
|
seedog
regular
Reged: 18/07/2006
Posts: 319
Loc: Bristol
|
|
As a newbie to BC I have spent some time looking at what I need to know and 'Wotayatties' comments about the curve are definitely worth considering. In the upper reaches of the Severn and the Avon the curve is distinctly bigger on the right than the left meaning the ebb is 'larger' than the flood which means the rule of 12ths is not accurate in those situations.
Intrigued to understand what is happening in Ramsay sound. Can someone explain?
|
Damo
regular
Reged: 22/02/2005
Posts: 2613
Loc: k keeper,Portishead
|
|
My main point earlier was that often the predicted times/heights from the curves don't agree with the reality on the day, so then the Rule of Twelfths is OK for practical purposes. You are right though that some areas are weird/extreme enough that it may be inadviseable. And the upper Severn Estuary is world-renowned for its wacky tidal behaviour!
And oddities such as Ramsay, the Solent, parts of the west coast of Scotland etc require a bit more local knowledge I understand
--------------------
Never be at a loose end with the Yosemite bowline
|
Previous
Index
Next
Threaded
Edit
Reply
Quote
