search ybw.com
 
Read the latest news from our sites  
Stolen flares spark false alarm...

Forum members report back >> MBM red diesel campaign

 |  Print Thread
Gludy
regular


Reged: 19/08/2001
Posts: 6704
Loc: Brecon, Wales
Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity
      18/09/2005 22:25

It seems that the use of red for commercial users is not under threat - many large boats are coded and available for charter - so lets take such a boat with say 20% private use and 80% charter use - what fuel pump would be used if red is stopped for pleasure boaters but not for commercial users?

Is it not absurd that a rib taking say 14 passengers around the coast on pleasure trips is commercial hence can use red - a charter boat taking executives for a ride is commercial and can use red but the same boat being used for your own pleasure would not be able to use red? What do you do - suck the red out and replace with white diesel?

Even a narrow definition of commercial as just say 'fishing' can be difficult - a charter boat that allows some fishing is surely a fishing boat? A boat taking out 6 anglers pleasure fishing for the day would surely be commercial.

So has anyone any idea how red will be protected for 'commercial vessels' - in other words what is a commercial vessel? How will those who dispense the fuel know what is commercial and what is not?

It seems totally absurd to claim that the rich have been hit when in practice an 80 foot charter boat at £7k per day uses red whilst a 25 foot power boat is banned from using it.

--------------------
Paul
St Francis 50 Cat
My Multihull Forum

Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator


Entire topic
Subject Posted by Posted on
* Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Gludy 18/09/2005 22:25
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity tcm   12/11/2005 23:30
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Admiral   19/09/2005 08:36
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Gludy   19/09/2005 09:01
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity robind   06/10/2005 16:37
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Gludy   06/10/2005 18:39
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity steverow   19/09/2005 03:24
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity andy_wilson   19/09/2005 20:10
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Gludy   19/09/2005 20:18
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Englander   01/10/2005 10:04
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Gludy   02/10/2005 23:56
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Fireball   03/10/2005 10:30
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Gludy   03/10/2005 11:55
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Fireball   03/10/2005 12:44
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Gludy   03/10/2005 15:42
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Scaramoosh   04/10/2005 13:54
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity DuncanMack   14/11/2005 21:38
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Gludy   15/11/2005 11:53
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity DuncanMack   16/11/2005 22:50
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Gludy   04/10/2005 14:03
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Gandy   04/10/2005 19:28
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity capsco   05/10/2005 11:13
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Marsupial   20/09/2005 08:36
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Gludy   20/09/2005 09:59
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Marsupial   21/09/2005 15:46
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Marsupial   20/09/2005 08:36
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity apollo   19/09/2005 13:44
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity LeytonC   19/09/2005 14:47
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity apollo   19/09/2005 14:52
. * * The rubbish that gets repeated ....... sorry and all that ! sbc   27/12/2005 15:02
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity LeytonC   19/09/2005 15:10
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity apollo   20/09/2005 09:26
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity steverow   21/09/2005 15:17
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity jrb1978   18/09/2005 22:44
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Gludy   19/09/2005 09:17
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity jrb1978   19/09/2005 09:24
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Gludy   19/09/2005 11:18
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity adrianm   23/09/2005 18:00
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Scaramoosh   19/09/2005 13:40
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity PCUK   12/11/2005 17:06
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Gludy   19/09/2005 16:07
. * * Re: Commercial Use of Red Diesel - an absurdity Lionel   19/09/2005 02:17

Extra information
0 registered and 1 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  danfoley 


Print Thread
Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      Mark-up is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 9990

Rate this thread

Jump to

Contact Us | Privacy statement YBW Home
Motor Boat and Yachting | Motor Boats Monthly | Practical Boat Owner | Classic Boat | Yachting Monthly | Yachting World
Your Motorboat | Your Yacht | Ships Monthly | IBI | European Boatbuilder | ybw.com
© IPC Media Ltd. All rights reserved. Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy
IPC Media DMA Trust UK