search ybw.com
 
Read the latest news from our sites  
Stolen flares spark false alarm...

Forum members report back >> MBM red diesel campaign

 |  Print Thread
Robih
regular


Reged: 29/11/2002
Posts: 1317
Loc: Hampshire
Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession"
      14/03/2004 11:23

All this talk of “ending the concession” is a bit odd to me, because I understood that whether red or white diesel was used for vehicles depended on whether it was being used as “road fuel” or not. Thus, Farmers, who put red diesel in their tractors, are entitled to do so because a tractor is not primarily a road vehicle. Likewise forklift trucks in yard premises where not taken on the road, and finally boats because they are clearly not using red diesel as road fuel.

I remember this because there was an issue a few years ago where farmers were hauling sugar beet to the factory with the new generation of “fast” tractors (these tractors do 40mph) and Customs were questioning their right to use red diesel because the vehicles were primarily being used as road vehicles. The final argument came down (I think) to whether these tractors had standard field tyres or whether they had fitted “road tyres”.

So, to remove the so called “concession for boats” as far as I can see the government have to change the law such that it is not determined by vehicle use but by some other method. If they don’t then surely farmers (and fork lift trucks and trawlers and council grass cutting machinery and lorries on container ports etc………………) will also all have to use white diesel instead of red.

If the government say well “leisure boats are to use white diesel” then I can see my boat having a LAN fitted on it pretty sharpish with a special lazerette for the server and fax! “No Sir, not a leisure boat but a floating office”

As for VAT, well the rule for boat diesel is nonsense. Because of something strange in the VAT Act we only pay 5% (on small quantities) of red diesel whereas we should pay the full 17.5% rate (farmers do!). So Gordon could go for that and I wouldn’t have such an objection. (The effect would be an increase from 35ppl to 39ppl which is 11%, fair do’s).

So, my message for Gordon is:

1) Leave red diesel law as it is (unless you are also taking on everybody else as well, don’t just stick the knife in to boaters)
2) You can have 17.5% VAT on boat diesel, that gives you some cash and it’s fair enough

Someone from the RYA must read this website I presume?......................

rob



Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator


Entire topic
Subject Posted by Posted on
* Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" Robih 14/03/2004 11:23
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" Robih   01/12/2007 15:29
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" roly_voya   21/03/2004 23:25
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" rex   02/04/2004 01:31
. * * Buy now and stock up Doffy   17/03/2004 15:53
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" neale   17/03/2004 11:17
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" asteven221   16/03/2004 20:53
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" Jools_of_Top_Cat   17/03/2004 00:46
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" Bergman   14/03/2004 20:20
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" Robih   14/03/2004 21:31
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" robind   14/03/2004 19:25
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" junksailor   14/03/2004 19:53
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" truebrit   14/03/2004 23:33
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" steverow   14/03/2004 23:22
. * * Without the formatting errors Robih   15/03/2004 06:42
. * * Re: Without the formatting errors Robih   15/03/2004 06:44
. * * Re: Without the formatting errors anchorhandler   15/03/2004 10:26
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" Dave1258   14/03/2004 20:17
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" Doffy   14/03/2004 19:01
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" Talon2   14/03/2004 17:54
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" Andrew_Fanner   14/03/2004 18:14
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" sonarbell   14/03/2004 17:51
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" Robih   14/03/2004 18:43
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" truebrit   14/03/2004 23:14
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" Tommyrot   14/03/2004 13:03
. * * Re: Red diesel - hang on this is no "concession" itsonlymoney   14/03/2004 11:34

Extra information
0 registered and 0 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  danfoley 


Print Thread
Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      Mark-up is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 4892

Rate this thread

Jump to

Contact Us | Privacy statement YBW Home
Motor Boat and Yachting | Motor Boats Monthly | Practical Boat Owner | Classic Boat | Yachting Monthly | Yachting World
Your Motorboat | Your Yacht | Ships Monthly | IBI | European Boatbuilder | ybw.com
© IPC Media Ltd. All rights reserved. Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy
IPC Media DMA Trust UK