The current Day Skipper course is on balance a good thing IMO. Making it strictly examinable rather than an overall judgement of competence based on four and a half days tuition and practice would almost certainly be counterproductive. However, if people feel strongly then perhaps they should get involved in the Cruisng Scheme and attempt to influence it.
Results 31 to 40 of 193
Thread: Life jacket legislation
12-05-12, 10:50 #31"You always have to defend the imagination against idiots.”
― Ursula K. Le Guin
12-05-12, 12:21 #32
Would making laws to force people to only cross the road at traffic lights or make you wear a crash helmet if you clean your upstairs windows, make people act any more 'sensibly'??
Of course not. People take risks with their own lives. Always will and should always be allowed to.
12-05-12, 12:32 #33
12-05-12, 12:37 #34Registered User
- Join Date
- Feb 2010
12-05-12, 13:54 #35Registered User
Location : Greenwich
- Join Date
- Mar 2002
Hope it doesnt become compulsory - I rarely wear one an my wife has sailed for 20 year now and I can't even persuade her to buy one.
I have little time for emergency equipment and prefer to spend money on safety equipment like decent sails and well maintained engine to keep me out of trouble. I do wear my lifejacket in rough weather and at night though simply because it is a a harness and therefore should prevent going overboard I hope.
Tenders when drunk do worry me a bit I admit so that's one place I might consider one. However it's my wife falls in at least twice a season late at night and I know she wouldn't go near a lifejacket.
12-05-12, 13:59 #36
There were 420 water-related deaths from accidents or natural causes across the UK in 2010.
The report, which uses the WAter Incident Database (WAID), reveals that, as in previous years, the highest number of fatalities - 217 (52 per cent) - happened in inland waters such as rivers, canals, lakes, lochs, reservoirs and ponds.
Nearly a quarter of fatalities - 94 (22 per cent) - happened at the coast or in a harbour, dock, marina or port, while an additional 73 deaths (17 per cent) happened out at sea.
Twenty-four fatalities were the result of incidents in baths (including jacuzzis or hot-tubs), six in swimming pools and six in areas that are not usually watercourses, such as flooded areas.
Although fatalities were spread across every day of the week and every month of the year, Saturday was the most common day and April and June the most common months for fatalities to occur.
WAID was developed by the NWSF to enable greater detail and volume in the collection of data on fatal and non-fatal drowning, other water-related deaths and injuries, and near misses. It collects incident data from a wide range of sources including the emergency services, sports governing bodies, coastguard, rescue services, coroners’ courts, and press reports.
WAID was developed by NWSF members, including: national partners - British Waterways, British Sub Aqua Club, Maritime and Coastguard Agency, Royal National Lifeboat Institution, RoSPA and Royal Life Saving Society; sports governing bodies; and regional and local organisations, including Cornwall Council. It has been developed in partnership with the Department for Transport.
12-05-12, 14:03 #37
Nobody is being "conditioned" into believing anything.
Perhaps you'd like to explain your hostility to lifejackets to the family, friends, 2 coastguard teams, 2 lifeboat crews, helicopter crew, police and paramedics who dealt with last weeks incident.
Ireland have had compulsory lifejackets for a couple of years now. Haven't noticed the imprisoning of the innocent and the death of the firstborn you seem to imply this would bring.
12-05-12, 14:12 #38
12-05-12, 14:18 #39
At some point you just have to accept that an accident happened. It was a sad outcome, but these things happen, and just get on with your own lives rather that constantly looking for some blame to associate with it.
12-05-12, 14:22 #40
I have a friend whose young brother was trapped under a capsized boat and drowned, because he was wearing a life jacket. So perhaps the use of life jackets should be banned ?Jeanneau Merry Fisher 805 For Sale. www.gooch.co.uk