I for one have been quite surprised at the number of incidents being reported by skippers so far. I am thinking of bits of kit failing, electrics going wrong, generator exhausts blowing off, spanners shorting across battery terminals etc, not to mention trawler collisions. Now, accidents happen as we all know, and these yachts are far more complex than anything that was sailed in the JAC08 however, given the number of team members that exist, the amount of time they have to prepare, the sponsorship and everything that gores towards making it what it is, that these potential race stoppers are happening. Or is it just over-eagre reporting I wonder ?
Occam's razor comes to mind... these boats are now so complex and built for speed (rather than a Jester boat that folk try to make 'bullet proof')... every new level of complexity must exponentially increase the risk of something going wrong - compound risks and all that (with the upside of course that if it goes well, it goes really well... that's the trade off I guess). I probably havn't expressed my thoughts very well.. but you get my drift? 'Keep it simple' seems to be a winning formula for Jesterites.
Location: Home Norfolk, Work in Yorkshire, Boat Brightlingsea
Posts: 3,789
Re: Vendee issues - lessons for us all ??
Agree with Boomshanka. These racing machines are built to be as light and fast as they can be, are probably very wet and then you add a load of high tech kit with loads of electronics. Is it any wonder they have problems!
Maybe in 20 years or so when they have sorted the issues and the prices have come down, then the 'ordinary' (if such a person exists) can buy the kit. Until then (and if I am still about) I shall keep to KISS as I am the second S! [img]/forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif[/img]
These are machines designed to push the boundaries of what's achievable. When you're sailing on the edge, sometimes you'll go over that edge.
It's like Formula 1 racing. These people are sailing / driving faster than I will ever sail / drive in state-of-the -art machines. But accidents are more frequent, and reliability is terrible. Wonderful to watch (if you like that sort of thing - personally, Formula 1 bores me rigid) and a potential testbed for new ideas / technologies that might one day be available to mortals, if we want them.
It's a different game. Vendee Globe is about as relevant to me, knocking about the Estuary, North Sea and possibly Atlantic, as Formula 1 is to getting to the sailing club in my old banger. Doesn't stop it being entertaining in its own right, though.
But there are lessons about preparation & approach. The Golden Globe race gave enough lessons there - the thoroughly tested slow boat winning through. And let's not even think of the corners you can paint yourself into by over-committment (think Crowhurst); which is why the organisers have received no entry from me, and won't unless and until I am a lot more ready than I am now.
ps - I'm the first S as well as the second!
__________________ Black Sheep. Not black, but sometimes sheepish
Location: Floating about whilst avoiding hitting Greece & Turkey in 2011
Posts: 1,242
Re: Vendee issues - lessons for us all ??
Things are/were probably not helped by their sailing straight out of Le Sables into a full blown Biscay Storm. The advantage that Jester Yachts or indeed any un-sponsored sailer has, is that when he sees a forecast like that issued for last Sunday & Monday, he can decide to defer his departure until Tuesday - or even Wednesday, it'll let the seas subside too.
__________________
You can have anything you want in life, but you can't have everything; choose carefully.
The thing that always gets me is the swinging keel. Without fail any given fleet of such boats is bound to have at least one develop problems with it, occasionally catastrophic.
There must be a better design. I can think of one, but I'm not boat builder, so perhaps it's not viable, but my thinking was a t section at the top of the keel, spreading near the beam of the boat. The rams could push down vertically, with leverage which would reduce the pressure required. Also, in the event of a hydraulic failure you could simply wedge a (pre fabricated) emergency solid bar between the deck and the internal keel "wing". Actually, you could go one better and do away with the rams and have motors turning screws. If the motors fail, you could do it manually. Either way, it's much safer than having a free swinging keel under the boat.
Still, as has been said, these things are the formula 1 of the boating worls and designed to be right on the edge of what is possible. That said, McLaren don't build their cars to cope with the southern ocean, so I'd like things considerably less towards the edge if I were onboard.
[ QUOTE ]
so I'd like things considerably less towards the edge if I were onboard
[/ QUOTE ]
Then you wouldn't win.
Why would someone who wanted to cruise around the world be interested in entering a race? The sport is about finding the balance between performance and durability, about knowing when to push and when to ease off, etc.
It's easy to be too conservative or even too reckless. It's getting the balance right that is hard. That's why they call the ones that manage it; 'winners'.
The point I was trying to make wasn't one surrounding the "leading edge design" or "sailing on the edge" nature of these boats. It was to do with the fact that basics on quite a few boats seem nopt to have been tested. Spanners falling across battery terminals, sparking and causing a fire, electrics failing etc etc etc smacks of ill-preparedness rather like RKJ had to suffer on his Velux trip. The keel issue will continue no dount, as that is the most critical bit of kit on the boat, and failures will continue until the balance has been reached.
What I was referring to was the basic preparation, not the limit pushing thing. Dont get me wrong, I have a go and blame no-one, it just seems that there are rather a lot of relatively silly things going wrong that could so easily have been avoided.
So there.
Vendee issues - lessons for us all ??
Linear Mode
