search ybw.com
 
Read the latest news from our sites  
Want to buy a submarine?...

Yachting and Boating World Forums >> Classic Boat Forum

 |  Print Thread
MASH
regular


Reged: 08/03/2004
Posts: 382
Loc: UK
Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea
      03/05/2008 18:35

Well, I've followed this extroardinary post for some time and cannot remain silent any longer.

It is clear that when cetain parts of history are discussed then no rationale will prevail which is a pity, but this is ludicrous!

A boat is a boat! A simple mechanical object. Who it belongs to, or belonged to, or who once used it is irrelevant, it is just a collection of steel and wood. It is a blameless inanimate object, and suggestions that it should be burned on acount of it's inadvertent part in history is as outrageous as suggesting that it's present or future owners are card-carrying members of the Nazi party. This is the "politics" (if I may so misuse the term) of hysteria, and utterly inappropriate to the subject in question.

Whether or not you chose to include Hermann Goering (not nasi goring, that is an Indonesian pork snack...) as one of the princilal evils of Nazism his yacht is nothing whatsoever to do with the argument, and those that demand it's destruction on account of it's owner's past are clearly not altogether on the plot.

If we are to burn all assets of past dictators we should;

a); Eradicate Paris and Berlin

b); Eradicate Rome

c); Eradicate N korea

d); Burn down the RAF museum at Hendon (Luftwaffe
history there)

e): Go to Duxford and burn Black Six

Or, perhaps, wake up, come into the 21st century and recognise that there is such a thing as history and that it is a crime to eradicate it on short-term PC cultural whims.

Wake up, people, this is a boat with a connection to history. How dare anyone imagine they have the right to eradicate such a historical exhibit on the basis of an historical offence, no matter how remotely involved?

Follow on this line of "reasoning" and we'll be demanding the destruction of all the ex Soviet Squre Riggers won't we?

Well, we will , won't we??? Yes, burn the Bolshevik [--word removed--]!

After all, Stalin butchered more than Hitler, didn't he?


So!!!

Let's get a sense of proportion here when we demand the destruction of as part of history!


Neither destroying history nor a corrosive hate across the generations is a constructive theme in a civilised society.

Burning books, history, people or boats is a suer sign that the bad guys have won.


Think about it!

Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator


Entire topic
Subject Posted by Posted on
* Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Metronicity 30/04/2008 07:34
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea B175Chris   05/05/2008 00:07
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea scottie   30/04/2008 11:27
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Englander   30/04/2008 11:31
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Chrusty1   30/04/2008 11:51
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea starfire   03/05/2008 08:30
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea No_Regrets   03/05/2008 10:13
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Alfie168   03/05/2008 17:25
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea MASH   03/05/2008 18:35
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Alfie168   03/05/2008 21:58
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Seagreen   03/05/2008 21:31
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Metronicity   04/05/2008 21:13
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Seagreen   05/05/2008 20:54
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Metronicity   04/05/2008 21:44
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Chrusty1   04/05/2008 22:37
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea 2nd_apprentice   05/05/2008 00:12
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea jordanbasset   05/05/2008 14:57
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Metronicity   06/05/2008 11:39
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea jordanbasset   06/05/2008 13:35
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Metronicity   06/05/2008 18:04
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Forbsie   06/05/2008 12:43
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Metronicity   06/05/2008 18:00
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea saltwater_gypsy   05/05/2008 13:49
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Blueboatman   03/05/2008 18:50
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea saltwater_gypsy   01/05/2008 13:23
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Seagreen   01/05/2008 21:26
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea oldfrank   30/04/2008 21:29
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Sneds   30/04/2008 18:11
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Chrusty1   30/04/2008 18:21
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Seagreen   30/04/2008 20:24
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Debutante21Sixpence   30/04/2008 22:24
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Englander   01/05/2008 11:02
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Debutante21Sixpence   01/05/2008 11:12
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Chrusty1   01/05/2008 06:27
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Sneds   01/05/2008 07:09
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Chrusty1   01/05/2008 07:21
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Clifford_Pope   01/05/2008 08:50
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Chrusty1   01/05/2008 09:22
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Snowgoose100   03/05/2008 22:37
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Chrusty1   04/05/2008 19:35
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Debutante21Sixpence   04/05/2008 02:20
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea 2nd_apprentice   04/05/2008 18:57
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Clifford_Pope   01/05/2008 10:13
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Chrusty1   01/05/2008 10:38
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea 2nd_apprentice   01/05/2008 00:23
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Debutante21Sixpence   01/05/2008 00:36
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea No_Regrets   30/04/2008 19:18
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea anteak   30/04/2008 17:31
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Seagreen   30/04/2008 10:08
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Chrusty1   30/04/2008 10:33
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea B175Chris   30/04/2008 10:34
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Clifford_Pope   30/04/2008 10:42
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Metronicity   30/04/2008 20:10
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea Chrusty1   30/04/2008 10:52
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea channelyacht   30/04/2008 10:35
. * * Re: Nazi Goering's Glamour Yacht "CARIN II" Found Lying in Red Sea noname   05/05/2008 20:52

Extra information
2 registered and 3 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  danfoley, louisebusby 


Print Thread
Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      Mark-up is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 5064

Rate this thread

Jump to

Contact Us | Privacy statement YBW Home
Motor Boat and Yachting | Motor Boats Monthly | Practical Boat Owner | Classic Boat | Yachting Monthly | Yachting World
Your Motorboat | Your Yacht | Ships Monthly | IBI | European Boatbuilder | ybw.com
© IPC Media Ltd. All rights reserved. Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy
IPC Media DMA Trust UK