search ybw.com
 
Read the latest news from our sites  
Cowes lifeboat taken over by RNLI...

Yachting and Boating World Forums >> Motor Boat Forum

 |  Print Thread
Beadle
regular


Reged: 20/08/2007
Posts: 1420
Re: gludy
      10/05/2008 23:19

Oh for goodness sake

Read the post

I never said or implied that staying out in storm conditions was preferable

Its a matter of balancing the risk.

There are many instances where staying out at sea is far safer than trying to enter a port (jumping out of the frying pan into the fire)

Surely the whole point is in f10-11 condx there are many harbours which are not safe to enter, Try a f10 N Easter anywhere on the East coast and you will be lucky to get in anywhere. There are perhaps 4 or 5 havens where you could get in between the Harwich and the Forth

I merely pointed out that a boat such as the one you are looking at buying makes that option less of a risk. I can well imagine the circumstances where I might (wrongly) try entry in a lightweight 26ft boat rather than stay out in bad condx. In a 50ft cat I would be much happier to ride it it out.

Isn't that why people buy bigger boats?

Similarly parking a small keel boat in strong winds in a crowded harbour is likely to be much less fraught than trying the same in a 50 ft cat, or at least you will do less damage.

You manage the risk as best you can - the big boat offers a different range of options

--------------------
"Every normal man must be tempted at times to spit on his hands, hoist the black flag, and begin to slit throats."

Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator


Entire topic
Subject Posted by Posted on
* A safe Harbour in a Storm Gludy 09/05/2008 10:04
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm Searush   09/05/2008 20:31
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm mikef   09/05/2008 11:49
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm blueglass   09/05/2008 19:45
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm mikef   09/05/2008 22:17
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm blueglass   10/05/2008 09:17
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm mikef   11/05/2008 21:04
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm Gludy   09/05/2008 23:03
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm hlb   10/05/2008 02:07
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm Chrusty1   10/05/2008 21:56
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm Gludy   10/05/2008 07:01
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm hlb   10/05/2008 17:00
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm Gludy   09/05/2008 11:51
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm mikef   09/05/2008 12:51
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm Gludy   09/05/2008 13:08
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm MapisM   09/05/2008 13:07
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm Gludy   09/05/2008 13:09
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm mikef   09/05/2008 13:44
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm Gludy   09/05/2008 13:48
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm Tonybob   10/05/2008 16:42
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm Gludy   10/05/2008 17:05
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm Beadle   10/05/2008 20:20
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm Gludy   10/05/2008 20:59
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm Beadle   10/05/2008 22:15
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm Gludy   10/05/2008 22:26
. * * Re: PS Beadle   10/05/2008 20:39
. * * Re: PS hlb   10/05/2008 20:49
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm hlb   10/05/2008 20:37
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm Gludy   10/05/2008 21:08
. * * Catch 22 MapisM   10/05/2008 20:58
. * * Re: Catch 22 hlb   10/05/2008 21:34
. * * Adds to sanity? MapisM   10/05/2008 22:05
. * * Re: Adds to sanity? hlb   10/05/2008 22:46
. * * Re: Adds to sanity? MapisM   11/05/2008 00:08
. * * Re: Adds to sanity? Gludy   10/05/2008 22:58
. * * gludy nyx2k   10/05/2008 21:41
. * * Re: gludy Beadle   10/05/2008 22:39
. * * Re: gludy Gludy   10/05/2008 22:53
. * * Re: gludy Beadle   10/05/2008 23:19
. * * Re: gludy Gludy   11/05/2008 00:07
. * * Re: gludy Beadle   11/05/2008 00:20
. * * Re: gludy hlb   10/05/2008 23:03
. * * Re: gludy BrendanS   10/05/2008 22:57
. * * Re: gludy Gludy   10/05/2008 23:06
. * * Re: gludy hlb   11/05/2008 00:40
. * * Re: gludy Gludy   11/05/2008 10:20
. * * Re: gludy hlb   11/05/2008 10:42
. * * Re: gludy hlb   11/05/2008 00:00
. * * Re: gludy Gludy   11/05/2008 00:12
. * * Re: gludy BrendanS   10/05/2008 23:22
. * * Re: gludy Gludy   11/05/2008 00:16
. * * Re: gludy Gludy   10/05/2008 22:16
. * * Re: gludy BrendanS   10/05/2008 22:27
. * * Re: gludy Gludy   10/05/2008 22:37
. * * Re: gludy BrendanS   10/05/2008 22:50
. * * Re: gludy Gludy   10/05/2008 23:02
. * * Re: gludy BrendanS   10/05/2008 23:04
. * * Re: gludy hlb   10/05/2008 21:47
. * * Re: Catch 22 Gludy   10/05/2008 21:14
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm nyx2k   10/05/2008 18:25
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm Gludy   10/05/2008 20:06
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm MapisM   09/05/2008 13:18
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm Chrusty1   09/05/2008 12:57
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm TigaWave   09/05/2008 11:30
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm deisel   09/05/2008 10:51
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm Gludy   09/05/2008 11:46
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm pir8ped   09/05/2008 10:59
. * * Re: A safe Harbour in a Storm Gludy   09/05/2008 11:50

Extra information
17 registered and 45 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:  danfoley 


Print Thread
Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      Mark-up is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 1759

Rate this thread

Jump to

Contact Us | Privacy statement YBW Home
Motor Boat and Yachting | Motor Boats Monthly | Practical Boat Owner | Classic Boat | Yachting Monthly | Yachting World
Your Motorboat | Your Yacht | Ships Monthly | IBI | European Boatbuilder | ybw.com
© IPC Media Ltd. All rights reserved. Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy
IPC Media DMA Trust UK