I do not deny that a dinghy might have saved them as could, possibly, various other options / permutations, but I do observe which one did save them. I do not attach importance to this case over and above the fact that it happened and the cause of the sinking should be included in Tranona's considerations / statements. The likelihood of needing a liferaft is very very low indeed (and I certainly hope that you, like me do not need one this season). Let people make up their own mind based on all the information, and the sailing they intend to pursue - it is certainly not about winning or losing a debate.