search ybw.com
 
Read the latest news from our sites  
Weather puts Class IIIC championships under threat...

Forum members report back >> Fouled sterngear reports requested

 |  Print Thread
alpha
regular


Reged: 18/11/2001
Posts: 192
Loc: UK
Re: Calshot - Lepe
      16/05/2004 18:42

Andrew Weir, in his excellent book 'The Tombstone Imperative', explains why it is that people generally DO have to die before change is actioned.

It would be extremely straightforward to enact legislation requiring all pot markers to be marked to a standard (flag, radar reflector, minimum pole height, automatic flashing light active at night, with identification marks indicating who the owner is).

My experience outside boating suggests that this legislation might rapidly follow a fatality, but will not come about without one. Really, we (reasonable people) should be able to do better.

So, how do we tackle this serious problem?

Is education (of the offenders) a possible answer? The CAA's general aviation safety department have made a huge success of 'roadshows' around the country preaching aviation safety messages - do we need something for boaters and fishermen? I think this could be a real winner - with RNLI involvement, it could be a strong tactic.

Should we (the motor boat community) get together to design and manufacture a 'standard' pot marker in sufficient numbers to equate to very low cost, and then actively market them - or offer them for free - to the fishermen?

Should we be more aggressive in tackling 'offenders' - when your sterngear is fouled, how could you track down the offending fisherman and prosecute, given present rules?

The present debate over light dues is a parallel. Most bouyage is handy, but not essential, for most of us. It doesn't provide genuine improvement in our ability to avoid hazard or reduce risk. Proper pot marking would, so do we need to join the two issues together somehow?

Go on, let's have some lateral thinking...


Post Extras Print Post   Remind Me!     Notify Moderator


Entire topic
Subject Posted by Posted on
* Confidential reporting kimhollamby 09/03/2004 13:05
. * * Re: Confidential reporting hshaky   27/08/2007 13:00
. * * Re: Confidential reporting jcmmarine   16/10/2006 22:24
. * * Re: Confidential reporting BrendanS   16/10/2006 23:01
. * * Re: Confidential reporting CHIRP_Director   09/02/2006 10:01
. * * Re: Confidential reporting blueglass   08/08/2006 19:26
. * * Re: Confidential reporting BrendanS   09/08/2006 00:44
. * * Re: Confidential reporting blueglass   09/08/2006 10:42
. * * Re: Confidential reporting CHIRP_Director   19/04/2007 14:17
. * * Re: Confidential reporting Llandissilio   28/01/2007 13:42
. * * Re: Confidential reporting Highlander2   12/03/2007 05:02
. * * Re: Confidential reporting Piloti   14/03/2007 15:54
. * * Re: Confidential reporting Highlander2   14/03/2007 23:28
. * * Re: Confidential reporting jollyjacktartheoceanpig   14/05/2005 01:57
. * * Re: Confidential reporting BrendanS   14/05/2005 12:44
. * * Re: Confidential reporting jollyjacktartheoceanpig   26/05/2005 00:43
. * * Re: Confidential reporting BrendanS   26/05/2005 02:56
. * * Re: Confidential reporting jollyjacktartheoceanpig   06/07/2005 23:55
. * * Re: Confidential reporting BrendanS   07/07/2005 00:29
. * * Re: Confidential reporting jollyjacktartheoceanpig   17/07/2005 19:17
. * * Re: Confidential reporting Zeewulf   16/10/2004 02:44
. * * Re: Confidential reporting Lifeboat   12/03/2005 00:53
. * * Re: Confidential reporting pelicanpete   09/02/2006 12:13
. * * Re: Confidential reporting duncan   24/02/2006 16:08
. * * Re: Confidential reporting fisherman   28/02/2006 19:46
. * * Re: Confidential reporting Morgana   14/02/2006 08:56
. * * Re: Confidential reporting BrendanS   12/03/2005 16:40
. * * Re: Confidential reporting MikeEchoPapa   01/05/2005 23:08
. * * Re: Confidential reporting PilotWolf   02/05/2005 00:18
. * * Re: Confidential reporting Lifeboat   12/03/2005 17:57
. * * Re: Confidential reporting Lifeboat   12/03/2005 11:26
. * * Re: Confidential reporting BrendanS   12/03/2005 16:41
. * * Re: Confidential reporting LordNelson   08/06/2004 07:24
. * * Re: Confidential reporting maxi   07/06/2004 15:05
. * * Ummm... kimhollamby   09/06/2004 19:34
. * * Re: Confidential reporting alpha   15/03/2004 20:29
. * * Re: Confidential reporting MarkJohnson12345   16/08/2006 10:30
. * * Re: Confidential reporting BobA   12/06/2004 19:36
. * * Calshot - Lepe maxi   13/04/2004 08:37
. * * Re: Calshot - Lepe S28   12/05/2005 08:01
. * * Re: Calshot - Lepe moodycruiser   12/07/2004 14:41
. * * Re: Calshot - Lepe Sunnyseeker   23/04/2004 08:24
. * * Re: Calshot - Lepe LordJohn   25/03/2007 13:42
. * * Re: Calshot - Lepe alpha   16/05/2004 18:42
. * * Re: Calshot - Lepe Planty   17/05/2004 16:36
. * * Re: Calshot - Lepe CaptainCava   03/06/2004 22:48
. * * Re: Confidential reporting mike_bryon   06/04/2004 14:26
. * * Re: Confidential reporting DavidP   20/03/2004 14:01
. * * Re: Confidential reporting WayneS   29/03/2004 18:24
. * * Re: Confidential reporting birdseye   10/03/2004 20:11

Extra information
0 registered and 0 anonymous users are browsing this forum.

Moderator:   


Print Thread
Forum Permissions
      You cannot start new topics
      You cannot reply to topics
      HTML is disabled
      Mark-up is enabled

Rating:
Thread views: 21634

Rate this thread

Jump to

Contact Us | Privacy statement YBW Home
Motor Boat and Yachting | Motor Boats Monthly | Practical Boat Owner | Classic Boat | Yachting Monthly | Yachting World
Your Motorboat | Your Yacht | Ships Monthly | IBI | European Boatbuilder | ybw.com
© IPC Media Ltd. All rights reserved. Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy
IPC Media DMA Trust UK